Skip to main content

Table 3 Model parameters extracted from studies that passed methodological review

From: Defining the landscape of patient harm after osteopathic manipulative treatment: synthesis of an adverse event model

Study reference number

AE severitya

AEs preceded by an OMT encounter

OMT encounters with post-OMT interval assessment

Post-OMT interval (days)

Cumulative incidence of post-OMT AEsb

Post-OMT interval-daysc

[22]

Mild

0

10

1

0.0

10

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[6]

Mild

45

1847

1

2.4

1847

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[23]

Mild

1

29

1

3.4

29

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[24]

Mild

2

10

1

20

10

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[11]

Mild

13

93

1

14

93

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[9]

Mild

2

17

1

11.8

17

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[25]

Mild

1

109

3

0.9

327

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[10]

Mild

4

63

3

11.1

189

Moderate

3

Severe

0

[26]

Mild

0

18

7

0.0

126

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[19]

Mild

36

298

7

12

2086

Moderate

0

Severe

1

[27]

Mild

39

66

7

59

462

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[28]

Mild

8

72

7

11.1

504

Moderate

0

Severe

0

[29]

Mild

10

1146

9

0.9

10,314

Moderate

0

Severe

0

Variables, formulae

X

Y

Z

([total X]/Y)*100%

Y*Z

  1. Legend: aEach AE reported in the literature was classified as an AE whether or not a causal relationship between the adverse patient outcome and preceding OMT encounter was reported. AE severity grades “life-threatening” and “death” are omitted from the table as no AEs were observed in either category across all modeled studies. bCumulative incidence of post-OMT AEs for each study was calculated as follows: ([total X]/Y)*100%. Cumulative incidence for each study was calculated across all AEs regardless of AE severity. cPost-OMT interval-days for each study was calculated as follows: Y*Z. AE Adverse event, OMT Osteopathic manipulative treatment