Skip to main content

Table 3 Responsiveness to change standardized mean responses

From: A multisite feasibility randomized clinical trial of mindfulness-based resilience training for aggression, stress, and health in law enforcement officers

Variable

Mean

Baseline

Mean

Post

Mean

3-month

Mean

6-month

SMR

Baseline to post

SMR

Baseline to 3-month

SMR

Baseline to 6-month

hs-CRP

 MBRT

1.22

.99

.90

--

.26

.35

--

 SME

.61

.80

.61

--

-.19

.00

--

 NIC

2.11

1.11

1.66

--

1.69

1.50

--

IL6

 MBRT

.55

.58

.37

--

-.06

.35

--

 SME

.37

.51

.39

--

-.31

-.07

--

 NIC

.28

.23

.23

--

.11

.11

--

IL10

 MBRT

.27

.20

.21

--

.14

.06

--

 SME

.28

.17

.18

--

.13

.38

--

 NIC

.16

.13

.11

--

.04

.07

--

TNF⍺

 MBRT

2.25

2.02

1.76

--

1.21

2.45

--

 SME

2.20

1.71

1.71

--

3.06

2.58

--

 NIC

1.87

1.70

1.66

--

.89

1.50

--

Attention Regulation

 MBRT

17.03

15.86

15.33

15.88

.10

.19

.07

 SME

16.00

13.50

9.30

9.53

.35

.67

.60

 NIC

31.42

30.71

25.35

29.23

.03

.13

.05

Interoceptive Awareness

 MBRT

3.88

4.24

3.98

4.19

-.63

-.47

-.53

 SME

3.91

3.92

4.08

4.06

-.02

-.38

-.29

 NIC

3.65

3.94

3.73

3.72

-1.07

-.21

-.23

Nonjudging

 MBRT

3.50

3.50

3.68

3.68

.00

-.25

-.26

 SME

3.48

3.60

3.42

3.33

-.23

.09

.25

 NIC

3.74

3.60

3.67

3.84

.24

.12

-.16

Nonreactivity

 MBRT

3.40

3.61

3.55

3.60

-.28

-.19

-.29

 SME

3.78

3.78

3.60

3.70

.00

.23

.10

 NIC

3.48

3.53

3.68

3.44

-.05

-.24

.04

Acting with Awareness

 MBRT

3.54

3.55

3.55

3.58

-.02

-.01

-.06

 SME

3.52

3.60

3.54

3.46

-.18

-.04

.09

 NIC

3.81

3.96

3.87

3.83

-.34

-.18

-.03

Self-Compassion

 MBRT

3.34

3.52

3.60

3.65

-.42

-.47

-.55

 SME

3.63

3.64

3.60

3.51

-.02

.06

.27

 NIC

3.22

3.49

3.50

3.46

-.75

-.93

-.60

Resilience

 MBRT

3.71

4.08

3.98

4.11

-.56

-.59

-.74

 SME

4.00

4.16

4.11

4.11

-.23

-.15

-.17

 NIC

3.96

4.02

4.02

3.57

-.23

-.30

1.15

Alcohol Use

 MBRT

46.61

46.95

48.00

47.82

-.06

-.20

-.23

 SME

45.10

46.85

47.70

44.43

-.27

-.39

.30

 NIC

45.52

46.94

46.43

50.57

-.30

-.12

-.68

Alcohol Use Negative Consequences

 MBRT

40.67

40.98

40.80

41.25

-.06

-.02

-.11

 SME

40.33

40.79

41.54

40.28

-.14

-.29

.04

 NIC

40.49

41.37

42.00

41.59

-.25

-.22

-.25

Perceived Stress

 MBRT

24.45

23.38

22.65

22.96

.22

.41

.21

 SME

22.57

21.93

23.42

23.30

.09

-.11

-.10

 NIC

21.50

21.30

22.07

22.38

.04

-.11

-.24

Aggression

 MBRT

1.93

1.71

1.62

1.57

.55

.70

.67

 SME

1.59

1.59

1.56

1.61

.00

.09

-.07

 NIC

1.67

1.74

1.69

1.58

-.25

-.04

.26

Depression

 MBRT

50.14

49.21

49.50

48.98

.15

.11

.13

 SME

47.41

46.78

48.78

48.16

.06

-.15

-.08

 NIC

47.60

46.43

46.85

44.78

.20

.19

.47

Sleep Difficulties

 MBRT

54.35

52.02

51.45

51.35

.33

.41

.47

 SME

52.37

54.47

52.81

49.52

-.23

-.06

.39

 NIC

52.82

51.76

52.41

51.30

.27

.08

.39

Burnout

 MBRT

2.40

2.39

2.34

2.32

.03

.21

.18

 SME

2.38

2.31

2.33

2.39

.26

.14

-.03

 NIC

2.35

2.29

2.34

2.35

.32

.04

.00

Suicidal Ideation

 MBRT

8.84

8.74

8.53

7.92

.05

.13

.45

 SME

7.63

7.66

8.00

7.92

-.02

-.24

-.11

 NIC

7.50

8.53

8.07

8.00

-.68

-.29

-.23

Trauma Symptoms

 MBRT

35.16

32.10

32.96

30.64

.33

.25

.52

 SME

32.10

29.60

32.42

32.07

.36

-.02

.00

 NIC

29.71

29.69

30.78

29.23

.00

-.22

.09

  1. SMR standardized mean response, MBRT Mindfulness-Based Resilience Training, SME Stress Management Education, NIC no intervention control, hs-CRP high sensitivity C-reactive protein, IL6 interleukin 6, IL10 interleukin 10 and 10, TNF⍺ tumor necrosis factor alpha